Menu
David Arnold Photography+
  • Home
  • Print Store
  • Experimental Originals
  • Blog
    • Frank Hurley, Antarctica, the Kodak Vest Pocket
    • Morning Glories: Lumen Print Making
    • Stones and Trees
    • Occasions
    • Churches of Stone
    • Borrowed Sources
    • A Point of Historical Interest—Toys Left for Julius.
    • Experimenting with Infrared Digital Capture
    • The Lego Camera: the Theory of Constraints For Creativity
    • Transfers
    • The Proposals Series
    • Experiments with Digital Noise
    • Experimenting with a Telephoto Lens
    • Using the Vest Pocket Kodak as an Experimental Lens
    • About The Experimental Condition
David Arnold Photography+
Angel Morning, Recoleta, Asuncion, Paraguay

Luminances, the Ceramic Portraits of the Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay

Posted on May 21, 2016October 29, 2020

Angel, Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay

Photographs possess the remarkable ability to close distances of time and space and bring forward the person, place, or thing which stood before the lens. Referred to as “photography’s transparency,” this quality remains photography’s most distinctive feature.[1] In 1843, shortly after the appearance of the first photographs, Victorian poet Elizabeth Barrett Browning upon seeing early daguerreotype portraits expressed a longing to possesses

“…a memorial of every being dear to me in the world. It is not merely the likeness, which is precious in such cases – but the association and the sense of nearness involved in the thing…”[2] [3]

Just over a hundred years later, the French theatre critics André Bazin would extend Browning:

“The photographic image is the object itself, the object freed from the conditions of time and space that govern it. No matter how fuzzy, distorted, or discolored, no matter how lacking, in documentary value the image may be, it shares, by virtue of the very process of its becoming, the being of the model of which it is the reproduction; it is the model.” Bazin found photography’s capacity to capture “the model” charmingly present in family albums, those “grey or sepia shadows, phantomlike and almost undecipherable” photographs which “embalms time.”[4]

In Camera Lucida, the French theorist Roland Barthes suggests

the “photograph is literally an emanation of the referent. From the real body, proceed radiations which ultimately touch me…I am delighted (or depressed) to know that the thing of the past, by its immediate radiations (its luminances), has really touched the surface which in its turn my gaze will touch…[In this way] the photographed body touches me with its own rays.” [5]

Certainly, a photograph is not as Bazin states “the object itself,” yet, we feel a unique closeness to the subjects of a photograph and even subjects who are strangers separated by cultures and long distances of time and space.

 Green-Cross. Walkway. Recoleta

Green Cross, Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay

While walking through the sprawling Recoleta Cemetery in Paraguay’s capital city of Asunción, I felt a strong affinity to photography’s distinctive phenomenology—this notion that photographs possess a trace of the subject and these traces or “luminances” which touch the surfaces of those photographed in turn touch us. The Recoleta Cemetery resembles a small city with mausoleums and tombs built in various sizes and architectural styles. With burial records dating back to 1842, the cemetery entombs much of Paraguay’s history. As the final resting place for former presidents, military officers, writers, musicians, and leading businessmen, the cemetery mirrors the chaotic development of the city at large, and contains luxurious mausoleums next to neglected and plundered graves.

 Blaces Crosses.Walkway.Recoleta

Black Cross, Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay

In the Recoleta, the tombs of the deceased are aligned along narrow walkways and are identified by family name. Many tombs prominently display bronze plaques to identify the deceased and still more are adorned with bronze plaques embedded with ceramic images of the deceased reproduced from family albums. The practice of firing photographs on enamel and glazed surfaces first appeared in the 1850s. The highly durable and permanent process lent itself to the expanding industry of gravestone design.[6] [7] Firing photographs onto ceramic surfaces is an experimental process that creates an exceptionally luminous image with depth and clarity, effectively transferring “luminances” through time and space. Echoing Browning, Bazin, and Barthes, the small photographs on the tombs of the Recoleta Cemetery brings the deceased powerfully forward into the present moment and touching those who wander the narrow pathways of the Recoleta Cemetery.

  • Juanita Villalba (1950), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Dr. Leandro P. Prieto (1958), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Aurora Luges de Romero (1899-1995), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Alberto Peccicacco (1963), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Americo Benitez (1967), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Fidela Elisa Gonzalez (1875-1949), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Eligia Rojas de Pasrtore (1915-1986), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Major De Sandao Niganor Cespedes (1912-1958), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Luis Frescura (1937), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Jose Maria Romero (1988-1940), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Jesus Jose Benitez Ciotti (1997), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Jadiyi Candia de Nunez (N.D.), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Zulma Francisca Garcete (1959), Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay
  • Recoleta Cemetery, Asunción, Paraguay, Americo Benitez tomb with ceramic portraits, center left.

David Arnold

Notes:

[1] Kendall L. Walton, “Transparent Pictures: On the Nature of Photographic Realism,” Critical Inquiry, Vol. 11, No. 2, (Dec., 1984), pp. 246-277, The University of Chicago Press
[2] Elizabeth Barrett Browning, from a letter written in 1843, quoted in Patrick Mayard, The Engine of Visualization: Thinking Through Photography, p. 232.
[3] Novelist and critic Susan Sontag quotes the Browning passage her seminal On Photography. Sontag makes the distinction between photographic and painted depictions. She refers to painting as an interpretation of the real and a photograph as a trace of the real. She claims that a barely legible photograph of Shakespeare would be more precious than a Holbein drawing of him. Susan Sontag, On Photography, p.183.
[4] André Bazin, “The Ontology of the Photographic Image.” Hugh Gray Film Quarterly, Vol. 13, No. 4. (Summer, 1960), pp. 4-9.
[5]Roland Barthes, Camera Lucida, pp. 80-81.
[6] Joy Neighbors, “Faces From the Past, Ceramic Memorial Plagues, A Grave Interest, May 18, 2012.
[7] Woodrow Carpenter, Enamel Photography, from Glass on Metal, Vol. 4, 1985. http://www.enamellers.nl/enamel-photography/. Feb. 2016.

Recent Posts

  • Infrared Street Photographs

    Infrared Street Photographs

  • St. Kilda—Nature, the Sublime, the Picturesque

    St. Kilda—Nature, the Sublime, the Picturesque

  • At Lacock Abbey: Talbot’s Latticed Window

    At Lacock Abbey: Talbot’s Latticed Window

  • Lumen Prints: Wildflowers

    Lumen Prints: Wildflowers

  • Photographing at the Sage Crest Drive-in

    Photographing at the Sage Crest Drive-in

  • Varanasi Streets | the ProCam App

    Varanasi Streets | the ProCam App

  • At Spenceville, Reflections in an Ephemeral Pond

    At Spenceville, Reflections in an Ephemeral Pond

  • Relics, In A Gold Country

    Relics, In A Gold Country

  • Experimenting with Infrared Full-Spectrum Photography

    Experimenting with Infrared Full-Spectrum Photography

  • Experimenting with Lens Blur: the Burnside 35mm Lens

    Experimenting with Lens Blur: the Burnside 35mm Lens

  • Edward Weston—At the Oceano Dunes

    Edward Weston—At the Oceano Dunes

  • Locating Dorothea Lange’s Migrant Mother

    Locating Dorothea Lange’s Migrant Mother

  • Negative Portraits In Silver

    Negative Portraits In Silver

  • British Cemeteries in the Ganges Valley, India

    British Cemeteries in the Ganges Valley, India

  • Found Photograph, Varanasi, a Story.

    Found Photograph, Varanasi, a Story.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

©David Arnold 2020